The World Has a Diamond Glut. Why Is That a Problem?

Mines are closing, and middlemen are being squeezed. But don’t inquire of bargains on the jewelry counter.

Credit scoreCredit scoreSam Panthaky/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images


LONDON — Is it ever imaginable to hold too many diamonds? For a few within the commerce of producing and procuring and selling these gemstones in most in style years, the answer is sure.

The pause diamond miners on this planet, in conjunction with the two perfect, Alrosa and De Beers, hold a list scenario. So function many of the cutters and polishers who take the tough stones and sell them to retailers. At each stage of the provision chain there are too many of these functional gem stones, whose marketing has long relied on their rarity.

A glut in many varied industries would ordinarily lead to deep ticket cuts. But patrons are procuring for stones that hold passed through many layers of middlemen: traders, polishers and cutters, who hold absorbed worthy of the raw stones’ ticket volatility, as successfully as brands and jewelry properties that originate rings, bracelets and necklaces. This has saved retail costs somewhat fixed, fueled by sturdy ask from purchasers all the perfect design through the realm.

Level-headed, challenges are mounting for the $17 billion diamond mining commerce. The oversupply of tough stones and the more and more strained finances of middlemen hold hit miners’ balance sheets in most in style months as they are making an strive to retain an eye on the surplus and magnify the rate of existing stones.

The Argyle mine, in a remote region of Western Australia, was to blame final yr for 10 million to 15 million carats of your total global diamond output (140 million to 145 million carats). Argyle is also the supply of one of the important most rarest, most pricey gemstones on this planet: pink, crimson and crimson diamonds.

Final month, at a showcase of 64 of presumably the most functional gemstones now no longer too long ago extracted from the mine, its owner, Rio Tinto, talked about Argyle would conclude in 2020, after years of speculation.

In mid-July, De Beers talked about it would chop reduction reduction manufacturing, after gross sales of tough diamonds fell 53 percent from a yr earlier. And a couple of days later, Petra Diamonds, a mining team listed on the London stock alternate, reported fleshy-yr income beneath analysts’ estimates, adding that it anticipated subsequent yr’s manufacturing to be even lower.

Credit scoreRio Tinto

Essentially based totally totally on Paul Zimnisky, an independent diamond commerce analyst and advisor, the market is being squeezed from both aspect. At one pause, because geopolitical tensions, global spending on luxurious jewelry has change into more volatile.

Extra important, a rising glut of tough diamonds, coupled with international alternate volatility, commerce wars and rocky stock markets, has upended the commerce. Costs for tough diamonds hold declined about 6 percent this yr, whereas polished stones are about 1 percent lower, in accordance with files from

Mine exploration boomed after the 2008 financial crisis, partly in anticipation of ask from China. “Rough diamond costs hit an all-time high in 2011,” Mr. Zimnisky talked about, “but hold in most cases been on a sprint since then.”

Because it takes four to eight years to invent most mining operations, and each as soon as in some time longer, stones from newer explorations didn’t hit the market till boring 2017 and early 2018, after procuring and selling circumstances had vastly shifted.

To boot, financing concerns hold affected the miners’ core buyer inappropriate: the traders, cutters and polishers of tough stones, whose hubs are predominantly in India and Belgium. Banks hold moved far from this advanced and secretive commerce, made up of tens of hundreds of runt and medium-size companies, after being stung by frauds and execrable loans. In February 2018, news broke of 1 in all India’s biggest frauds, allegedly perpetrated by a renowned trader and jeweler, Nirav Modi.

Final month, the Dutch bank ABN Amro was presumably the most in style to drawl that it would scale reduction its financing of tough-diamond purchases, citing a shortage of profitability.

“There might be critical indigestion within the midstream of the market, thanks to each a unfavorable cocktail of most in style geopolitics and now this credit squeeze on polishers and traders,” talked about Bruce Cleaver, the manager govt of De Beers. “The impact is being felt across your total market.”


Credit scoreTom Jamieson for The Novel York Instances

With the profit margins of its clients — traders, cutters and polishers — rapid slipping away, De Beers talked about it had lowered tough diamond manufacturing by 11 percent for the dear half of 2019. It also chop reduction costs and supplied alternatives love deferring purchases. A weaker rupee has also made gemstones more pricey for Indian producers, which chop reduction or polish about 90 percent of the realm’s stones within the city of Surat.

“We must wait on potentialities dash out this storm,” Mr. Cleaver talked about. “That talked about, we’ve seen procuring and selling downturns love this earlier than. There might be soundless an excellent deal of ask for diamonds from patrons, and I if truth be told feel confident this would hunch.”

Rio Tinto talked about the main reason for shutting down Argyle was now no longer that there was a shortage of ask, but that the mine’s last stones weren’t functional enough to extract, which involves sifting through 100 a full bunch a rock known as kimberlite to glean a single carat.

But the shutdown would maybe also by some means wait on the commerce.

The Argyle mine has produced about 865 million carats of tough diamonds since 1983, Mr. Zimnisky talked about. Correct over one million, or 0.13 percent, hold been labeled as pink, a rarity that tends to safe several million dollars per carat, however the bulk hold been lower-quality browns and whites. Losing those browns and whites will knock 10 percent out of the annual world diamond output and would maybe also rebalance supply and ask. The shutdown would maybe also snatch the costs of pink diamonds already within the fingers of traders.

The closing of a mine love Argyle and an incremental decrease in diamond output would maybe also wait on shift some force far from runt and medium-size traders and sharpening companies to increased, better-financed companies that can weather the volatility attributable to excess stock.


Credit scoreRio Tinto

Miners hold also greatly lowered investment in exploration over the previous decade. Bain & Company estimates that exploration spending as a percentage of income has fallen to 2 percent from about 8 percent in 2007-08.

“Given where costs are if truth be told, there is a risk that one of the important most mines that hold commenced manufacturing in most in style years received’t live to verbalize the tale presumably the most in style atmosphere and be positioned on care and repairs,” Mr. Zimnisky talked about.

The blossoming reputation of lab-grown diamonds — and manufacturing in China and India — is one more doable headwind for miners of natural gemstones. Whereas lab-grown stones make up easiest about 2 percent of the diamond jewelry market, manufacturing is rising by 15 to 20 percent a yr, in accordance with Bain. Artificial diamonds can price 30 to 75 percent lower than natural stones.

Level-headed, user lag for meals for natural diamonds is solid.

Essentially based totally totally on a Bain Global Diamond Industry represent final yr, diamond jewelry gross sales increased 2 percent in 2017, led by ask within the united states, which accounts for more than half the polished natural diamond market, and China, which makes up 15 percent.

For Mr. Zimnisky, the regular user ask is reassuring, though he remains cautious.

“A diamond would maybe also very successfully be without a ruin in sight,” he talked about. “But its allure comes and goes.”

Elizabeth Paton is a reporter for the Styles half, covering the style and luxurious sectors in Europe. Earlier than becoming a member of The Instances in 2015, she was a reporter on the Monetary Instances each in London and Novel York. @LizziePaton

Read Extra